Tuesday, December 29, 2015

Introduction

Is Philosophy a science?

The study of Morality and Ethics: Philosophy or Social Science?

"Areas" of Philosophical Inquiry:


Cultural/Historical “origins” of “morality” in Western Civilization

1 Judaism

2 Greek and Hellenistic Civilization
- Eudemonia
- Socrates (469-399 BCE)
- Plato (427-347 BCE)
- Aristotle (384-322 BCE)
- Early Christianity

3 Roman and Medieval Civilization
-    Stoicism (& other Hellenistic philosophies: Epicureanism, Skepticism, Cynicism)
-    Platonic Catholicism
-    Aristotelian Catholicism (Scholasticism)

4 Renaissance and Reformation  ( 13th-17th centuries; 1517-1648(?) )
A) Rise of Middle Class
B) Northern Europe: Luther and Calvin
C) English Reformation:
-    Henry VIII/Anglicanism (1491-1509)
-    Later: Congregationalism, Calvinism, various sectaries.
-    Civil Wars (1640s)
-    Locke & Glorious Revolution   (1632-1704; 1688)
-    English Common Law

5 Modern Period


Philosophers and Ethics:
Jefferson, 2, "He wanted to be remembered not for his presidency, but for the roles he played in the creation of the Declaration of Independence, the Virginia Statute of Religious Freedom and the University of Virginia."
"The Good Old Cause"
Puritan Origins
Origins

From Thiroux & Krasemann:

On analytic philosophy: "...these philosophers feel that they might as well do what other specialists have done and concentrate on language and logic rather than attempt to arrive at ethical systems that will help human beings live together more meaningfully and ethcially" (6).

Kaplan:  Is it not possible that concentrating on logic and language can help us to live together more meaningfully and ethically?

Course syllabus:



COURSE NUMBER:           PHL 2130-003/-004
COURSE NAME:                Ethics
CREDIT HOURS:               3                                             
CONTACT HOURS:           3
INSTRUCTOR:                    Dr. Carter Kaplan
OFFICE HOURS:                     M 10:00-10:30 am, 1:30-2:00 pm, 5:30-6:00 pm; T 1:30-2:30 pm;
W 10:00-10:30 am, 1:30-2:00 pm; R 1:30-2:30 pm, 5:30-6:00 pm;
and by appointment
MAILBOX:                           28
PHONE EXTENSION:        x1152 (preferred method of contact)                      
EMAIL ADDRESS:             ckaplan@belmontcollege.edu (use the telephone, please)

 I.         COURSE DESCRIPTION:  Discussion of classic and modern philosophical views of human values, ideals, and morality.

 II.       PREREQUISITE:  Placement.

III.       COURSE OBJECTIVES:  This course presents an overview of classical and modern human values, ideals, and morality through exposure to the views and approaches to specific issues in Ethics as presented in the writings of several figures/texts from both classical and contemporary histories of Philosophy.  Within the context of the three major areas with which Ethics is concerned : (1) The search for universal moral principles and absolutes, (2) ethical confusion, and (3) the search for the good and meaningful life, students will be exposed to basic ethical concepts and ethical theories such as absolutism, descriptivism, relativism, naturalism, intuitionism, utilitarianism, Kantianism, and virtue ethics, and will be asked to demonstrate increased awareness and understanding of complex issues related to these concepts and theories as presented in philosophic texts.  Students will be asked to demonstrate an understanding of the examination of issues from a diverse perspective, recognize arguments addressing traditional and contemporary ethical and moral issues, comprehend, analyze, and evaluate diverse ethical and philosophical arguments within the contexts and traditions where they are cast, and represent complex philosophical ideas, theories, and perspectives fairly, objectively, and critically.  Throughout the course students will be engaged in oral and written reflective response.

 IV.      LEARNING OUTCOMES:  The central focus of this course is for students to learn enough about Ethics as a part of Philosophy, to be able to critically examine their personal system of values, ideals, decision-making, and definition and pursuit of the good and meaningful life for themselves, moving toward making themselves wiser, more self-reflective and therefore more whole men and women. This central focus is to be achieved through the accomplishment of the following learning outcomes:
  1. Demonstrate exposure to and knowledge of the views and approaches to specific issues in ethics as presented in the writings of several figures/texts from the history of philosophy.
  2. Demonstrate exposure to and knowledge of the views and approaches to specific moral problems or ethical issues as presented in the writings of several figures/texts from contemporary philosophy.
  3. Recognize basic ethical concepts and ethical theories, such as absolutism, descriptivism, relativism, absolutism, naturalism, intuitionism, utilitarianism, Kantianism, and virtue ethics.
  4. Demonstrate increased awareness and understanding of complex issues and complex ethical issues as presented in philosophic texts.
  5. Demonstrate an understanding of how to examine questions and issues from diverse perspectives.
  6. Demonstrate exposure to and recognition of philosophical arguments addressing traditional and contemporary ethical and moral issues within the contexts and traditions that inform them.
  7. Comprehend, analyze, and evaluate diverse philosophical arguments regarding ethical matters within the contexts and traditions where those matters are cast.
  8. Develop the ability to (re)present complex philosophical ideas, theories, and perspectives fairly, objectively, and critically.
  9. Engage in the development of written reflection and response.

  V.      BELMONT COLLEGE CORE LEARNING OUTCOMES PHILOSOPHY:  The following general education core learning outcomes are cultivated in all students seeking the Associate Degree and/or Certificate and are imbedded in all of the learning outcomes of this course:

            1.         Communicate Effectively (Written, Oral, Reading)
            2.         Think Critically and Creatively
            3.         Learn Actively
4.         Accept Accountability
5.         Build Global/Multicultural Diversity Awareness

            While the core learning outcomes are not specifically quantitatively measured in this class, they are implied and are subjective criteria for success in measurement and evaluation of all nine learning outcomes.

VI.  MATERIALS REQUIRED:  

            Jacques P. Thiroux and Keith W. Krasemann, Ethics: Theory and Practice, Eleventh
                                 Edition/Updated. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey:  Prentice-Hall, 2015/2017.
            https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/
            Notebook
            USB flash drive

VII.  SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIALS AVAILABLE:  The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (SEP) http://plato.stanford.edu/  is the primary on-line resource for students to review course concepts and terms. Students should examine related Stanford articles as they pursue the assigned readings in the textbook. Extensive supplementary materials related to Ethics are available in the Learning Commons. Recommended sources for term papers are the 60-volume set of The Great Books of the Western World, The Dictionary of Philosophy and Psychology, The Cambridge Dictionary of Philosophy, Routledge Encyclopedia of Philosophy, The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, and The Oxford Companion to Philosophy, plus numerous individual works either by or about many of the authors listed in the course calendar.  Additional lists or journals, periodicals, and videos related to Ethics are available in the Learning Commons and through the Instructor.  Students are encouraged to use these resources in completing term papers. Supplemental Notes:  www.kaplanethics.blogspot.com

VIII. INSTRUCTIONAL METHODS:  The primary instructional methods in this class are lecture and discussion reflecting upon readings from the textbook, handouts and the internet.   Video is used occasionally to amplify certain issues and topics.

IX.   COURSE REQUIREMENTS/POLICIES: Expectations for student behavior that may contribute to successfully completing the course are listed below.  There are no special class requirements other than consistency, responsibility, accountability, and a dedication to learning with an open mind.  The absence policy is listed below.  Make-up and late assignment policies are included in course evaluation methods.  Acceptable and unacceptable behavior in the classroom and online are described in the Code of Conduct and Code of Academic Conduct.

Requirements for the Student:  Any student having any concerns about class is encouraged to bring these concerns directly to the Instructor. Students should not drop or withdraw from the class without first discussing it with the Instructor. The Instructor and Belmont College want all students to complete the course. If the student is having personal, family, and/or academic difficulties, the Instructor will do everything that is rationally and reasonably possible to assist the student.

Students are encouraged to contact the instructor and/or advisor before withdrawing from the course.  In any case, the student must follow procedures outlined in the college catalog to withdraw from the course. If any student is concerned about their grade for the class, they should immediately contact the instructor for guidance.

Special Class Requirements: 
    
Absence Policy:  Students must come to class, read the textbook, and take good notes in class.  Exam questions are taken from the lecture, textbook, handouts, videotapes, and other materials distributed in class, with a considerable emphasis on the class lectures. There are many perspectives in Ethics and Ethics as part of Philosophy, and students are required to pay particular attention to all materials—lectures, handouts, videotapes, and any other materials. Since there is considerable variance in these perspectives, students should not expect lecture materials to necessarily be the same as that in the textbook, but are responsible for all perspectives presented in any medium. Students are responsible on examinations for all assigned reading material, whether it is covered in class or not.

 Attendance and participation are important components of this course.  Attendance records will be kept.   Students who miss five (003)/three (004) classes can expect to have their final grades lowered by one letter. Six (003)/Four (004) or more absences will result in failure No exceptions. Students must contact the instructor in advance if they plan to miss class. Leaving class meetings early will be counted as an absence.  Coming to class unprepared will be counted as an absence. Excessive tardiness can also lower the final grade. Two incidents of tardiness will be counted as an absence. Students should be aware that the Department of Education has certain attendance requirements concerning student eligibility for student aid.

Students are strongly encouraged to attend all classes. Poor attendance will initiate that an “Early Alert” will be sent to administration indicating a concern for your final grade. A conference between the student and the instructor regarding the student’s future progress in this class may be scheduled at the student’s request. This policy is a result of criteria established by student grants requiring attendance verification, and by the efforts of Belmont College to provide academic quality.

The student is to notify the instructor within one week of his/her knowledge that he/she is unable to finish attending classes due to personal reasons, job requirements, etc. It will be determined then, if it is in the best interest of the student to finish or drop the course. No consideration will be afforded students that fail to inform the instructor/professor in advance when a conflict of interest occurs.

Make-Up Policy:  No make-up exams will be given on the mid-term exam.  If a student misses the mid-term examination, 80 percent of the student’s final grade for the course will rest on the final examination.  No make-up examinations will be given on the final examination during the last week of the semester.  If a student fails to take the final exam, for any reason, he/she must, as quickly as possible, make arrangements with the Instructor to take an Incomplete and arrange to complete work necessary for eradicating the Incomplete as soon as possible after the following semester starts, within the allotted time frame of three weeks, as designated by college policy.

College Closure or Instructor Absence: If the college is closed due to inclement weather or other unforeseen circumstances or if an instructor is absent from class, student assignments for the class period will be posted on the course portal or emailed to students.  Contingency plans are also provided in the course syllabus in the Major Areas of Study section if students lack internet access.  Students will be responsible for completing the missed assignments according to the faculty member’s instructions.  Students are encouraged to email the instructor for clarification of any assignments.

Late Assignment Policy:  Please discuss any make-up possibilities or late assignments with the instructor prior to the assignment due date. Late assignments are accepted at the discretion of the instructor.

Classroom/Online Etiquette: Students should demonstrate respect for the learning environment, including their fellow students, and contribute to an atmosphere conducive to productive group discussion and learning. 

Belmont College expects students to respect the rights and privileges of others, and to be responsible for self-conduct.  See the College catalog for the Student Code of Conduct.   Students who engage in unacceptable behavior after a warning may be referred to college administration and may receive an “F” for the course.

It is expected that the student will maintain an appropriate level of professionalism as outlined in the College Student Handbook. These rules are "be respectful and be polite to each other" and "be patient and considerate of others". 

In the classroom, please set cellphones to “vibrate”.  If someone calls, please leave the classroom and talk in the corridor. There is no need to excuse yourself. Excessive cellphone activity is disruptive and will result in an Academic Alert, and/or a possible “zero for the day” record in the gradebook.

Withdrawal from Classes: Before withdrawing from classes, students should consult their instructor as well as other appropriate college offices. Withdrawing from classes may negatively impact a student’s financial aid award and his or her semester charges. To discuss financial aid, visit the Office of Student Financial Aid regarding the impact on your financial aid.

Student Financial Responsibility:  Students assume the responsibility of full payment of tuition and fees generated from their registration and all charges for books and supplies, and other applicable miscellaneous charges. Students are ultimately responsible for any unpaid balance on their account as a result of the Office of Student Financial Aid or their third party sponsor canceling or reducing their award(s).  Please remember that you must attend class or participate in online courses to remain eligible for Federal Student Aid.

X.   COURSE EVALUATION METHODS:

Examinations

There will be two examinations. The Mid-term Examination will cover from the first class to the last class before the Mid-term Exam.

The Final Examination is comprehensive, and will consist of five questions that will ask students to incorporate all of the information they have learned from the entire course into a practical, integrated understanding of Ethical principles and issues applied to an examination and evaluation of self.

            The Mid-term Examination is worth 30 percent of the student’s final grade for the course.  The Final Examination is worth 40 percent of the student’s final grade for the course.

If a student makes less than a “C” on the mid-term examination, he/she may schedule an appointment with the Instructor to evaluate and consider what might have been done differently to have better achieved the objectives of the course at mid-term, and to consider what he/she may do to improve toward the final examination. Students are also encouraged to do the optional book reviews in areas of their weaknesses as reflected by the mid-term examination. If a student makes less than a “C” for the course, he/she may schedule an appointment with the Instructor in the following semester to evaluate and consider what he/she might have done differently to achieve the objectives of the course, and will still be given the opportunity to meet those objectives. Otherwise, unless requested, final examinations are not returned to the students, and if the student makes at least a “C” or above for the course, final examinations will not be returned at all.

            Make-up Examinations

No make-up exams will be given on the mid-term exam.  If a student misses the mid-term examination, 80 percent of the student’s final grade for the course will rest on the final examination.  No make-up examinations will be given on the final examination during the last week of the semester.  If a student fails to take the final exam, for any reason, he/she must, as quickly as possible, make arrangements with the Instructor to take an Incomplete and arrange to complete work necessary for eradicating the Incomplete as soon as possible after the following semester starts, within the allotted time frame of three weeks, as designated by college policy.

Notes

Several times during the semester, the instructor will collect notebooks to insure that students are keeping up with lectures and discussion. These collections will be unannounced. Incomplete, illegible, or neglected notebooks will lower the grade for class participation. The standard grading scale will be applied.
           
             Term Paper

The course requires the submission of a term paper. Students should write a term paper based on subject matter described in Objectives 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 on Page 2. Technical details for writing term papers will be given in class. The term paper comprises 20 percent of the student’s final grade for the course.  Further details regarding term papers appear under XIII (Writing Across the Curriculum Assignment).

            Evaluation Method

The grade scale for this course is as follows:

93 - 100 = A
73 - 76.9 = C
90 - 92.9 = A-
70 - 72.9 = C-
87 - 89.9 = B+
67 - 69.9 = D+
83 - 86.9 = B
60 - 66.9 = D
80 - 82.9 = B-
0 - 59.9 = F
77 - 79.9 = C+


On a four-point system, there is no A+ and no D-.

Assignments:
           
            Participation and Notes                      5%
            Mid-Term                                            25%
            Term Paper                                          20%
            Brief Oral Presentation of Term Paper          5%
            Final Examination                               35%

            Total:                                                  100%              
           
Term Papers are due on the dates indicated on the schedule. Term Papers turned in late for any reason will be penalized one letter grade.  This rule will be strictly enforced. There will be no exceptions. No term paper will be accepted before its due date, and no exam may be taken early.

XI.  STUDENT CONCERNS:   Any student having any concerns about class is encouraged to bring these concerns directly to the Instructor. Students should not drop or withdraw from the class without first discussing it with the Instructor. The Instructor and Belmont College want all students to complete the course. If the student is having personal, family, and/or academic difficulties, the Instructor will do everything that is rationally and reasonably possible to assist the student.

Students are encouraged to contact the instructor and/or advisor before withdrawing from the course.  In any case, the student must follow procedures outlined in the college catalog to withdraw from the course. If any student is concerned about their grade for the class, they should immediately contact the instructor for guidance.

XII.COLLEGE POLICIES:

Americans with Disabilities Act:  It is the policy of Belmont College to provide reasonable accommodation to persons with disabilities. If you have a physical, mental or learning disability and wish to request such accommodation, you must contact the Access Advisor or Student Services on the main campus, or the Student Advisor at the Harrison County Center and Monroe County Center.

Academic Misconduct: The responsibility for academic honesty rests with the student. The College expects the student to submit papers, projects, and reports resulting from the student’s own efforts. Work submitted in any form should reflect the exclusive effort of the student. It is assumed that mature learners do not practice cheating on quizzes, tests, or examinations. Plagiarism will not be tolerated at any time. Submitting another’s work as one’s own, in part or in whole, is a dishonest practice. A student may not appropriate another person’s ideas, whether published or not. Consequences for proven cases of dishonest practices may include:
a.       Zero percent being given for the test, examination, report, quiz, paper, project, or any other course requirement on which the cheating has occurred; or
b.      Failure for the course in which the offense occurred; or
c.       Dismissal from the College.

Waiting Policy: If an instructor is detained from a class longer than fifteen minutes for any reason, one student should report the absence to the reception desk. Remaining students will wait in the classroom until the reporting student returns.

Code of Conduct: Belmont College expects students to respect the rights and privileges of others, and to be responsible for self-conduct. The full policy is available in the college catalog at the Belmont College Website.

Other College Policies: See the other policies enumerated in the current college catalog at the Belmont College website.

XIII.  MISCELLANEOUS:

Tips for Success:

Students need to attend class, take good notes, and read the textbook.  They must not procrastinate or wait until the last minute to complete assignments or study for exams.  If they are struggling or need help, they should by all means talk to the Instructor or consult one of the resources listed below.


Support Services:



Belmont College has a variety of support services for students including the Tutoring, and Advising Staff, the Learning Commons, the Charles W. Kocher Student Success Center. Drop-in and individually scheduled tutor support is available, both on campus and online, through the Student Success Center (SSC).  Enquire in the SSC also about individualized tutoring assistance for all courses.  The Learning Commons/Library offers help and materials to support learning.  Materials include free use of computers and other equipment, as well as books, articles, videos, and multimedia resources.  Materials are located within the library, accessed online using a library card, or easily requested from colleges and universities throughout Ohio through OhioLINK.  Technical support is provided by the Support Desk at 740-695-9500 x1137 or by e-mail at: supportdesk@belmontcollege.edu




XIV.    MAJOR AREAS OF STUDY TO BE COVERED/STUDY UNITS/COURSE CALENDAR: Changes in this schedule will be announced by the instructor.


Week
Topics
1



Ch. 1
Introduction – Study of Philosophy, Morality and Ethics – What is Philosophy? (Plato, Aristotle, Kant, Mill, Locke, Wittgenstein as examples)


2



Ch. 1, 2
Morality and Ethics – Relationship of Philosophy to Ethics (Plato, Aristotle, Kant, Bentham, Locke, Jefferson as examples)




3

Ch. 2
Consequentialist (Teleological) Theories of Morality (Psychological Egoism; Ayn Rand’s Rational Ethical Egoism)



4


Ch. 2
Consequentialist (Teleological) Theories of Morality (John Stuart Mill, Jeremy Bentham, William James)

Practice Test – Extra Credit



5


Ch. 3, Marlin handout
Nonconsequentialist (Deontological) Theories of Morality (Immanuel Kant’s Duty Ethics; Sir William David Ross’ Prima Facie Duties, Ethical Intuitionism)



6


Ch. 3, 4
Ethics in the Professions: John Marlin, “Cynicism and Careerism: Threats to Army Ethics.”
Introduction to Virtue Ethics

7


Ch. 4
Virtue Ethics (Aristotle’s Ethics, Confucian Moral Self-Cultivation).
Review for Midterm



8


 Ch. 1-4,
Midterm Examination


9



 Ch. 5, Anscombe handout
Midterm discussion
Term paper discussion

Absolutism (Kant, Ron), Relativism (Isiah Berlin, Joseph Margolis) Naturalism (Simon Blackburn, G.E. Moore), Intuitionism (Michael Huemer), Descriptivism (Gottlob Frege, Bertrand Russell, David Chatham)



10


 Ch. 5
Absolutism  vs. Relativism, continued
Term paper discussion



11


 Ch. 6
Freedom vs. Determinism (Calvin, Newton, Darwin, Marx, Freud, Skinner, Hospers, Sartre, Frankl, Freud);



12

 Ch. 6, 7
Reward and Punishment.
Political Philosophy and Human Rights
Term Paper Subject Due


13

Ch. 7
Term Paper Discussion


14

Ch. 7, 8
Political Philosophy and Human Rights
Setting Up a Moral System:  Basic Assumptions and Basic Principles


15

 Ch. 1-8
Term paper due, with brief oral presentation

Review for Final


16


Comprehensive Final Examination




17
TBA